LAPD Disclaimer

  • Comments are moderated, and will not appear on this weblog until the monitor has approved them. We encourage you to express your opinions about current events through respectful and insightful discussion. The Department reserves the right to refuse to post those comments that contain inappropriate language and/or material. Additionally, hyper-links or E-mail addresses will not be posted. To report or help us solve a crime go to lapdonline.org. To commend an employee or report employee misconduct - click here.

LAPD Photos

  • www.flickr.com

Translate


  • Disclaimer: The LAPDonline.org® website has made reasonable efforts to provide an accurate translation. However, no automated or computerized translation is perfect and is not intended to replace human or traditional translation methods. The official text is the English version of the LAPDonline.org® website. If any questions arise concerning the accuracy of the information presented by the translated version of the website, please refer to the English edition of the website, which is the official version.

Become a Fan

LAPD Blog RSS Feed

« Man Murdered in Broad Daylight on Busy City Street | Main | Woman Arrested for Fatal Shooting on Skid Row »

November 24, 2024

Comments

While I tend to agree that Chief Beck has the authority to appoint his command staff, I believe such appointments should be based on experience and work performance. Jimmy McDonnell had 7 years serving as acting Police Chief for Bill Bratton (who spent most of his time anywhere other than LA). He served capably, but now he's not good enough to continue in his Assistant Chief position? Sharon Papa seemed like a capable command staff officer, but what did she do to earn a two-step demotion? Although Mike Moore is not a morale booster for field officers, his finishing #1 in the initial COP rankings earns him an Assistant Chief position. Sandy Jo MacArthur...A nice woman but what field command experience does she have? Even though Chief Beck has basically created a glorified secretarial position for her, there could come a time when Ms. MacArthur may have to command the troops in the field, but she has neither the training or experience to do so. Pat Gannon was an excellent choice for Deputy Chief. He is a fair man. His field experience and work ethic will serve South Bureau well.

Selection to a command position within a large metropolitan police department is not always based upon experience or performance. There are many qualities that may come into play depending upon the specific job and the specific vision the Chief of Police has for that job. Political astuteness, collaboration skills, friendliness or even ruthlessness are just some examples. They are all social attributes that impact such decisions. Movement to or from a command or a rank often tells far less than might be implied. Building a command team is a sort of musical chairs. Not everyone can be a winner. Chief Beck held accountable for the consequences of his leadership team's efforts and therefore he gets a free hand in its selection. It's just that simple.

Every Chief has a command style supported by his staff. In the selection of these people there are certainly personality issues involved as are the more obvious attributes such as experience and tenure. Some of the previous command staff were apparently promoted to their position based on factors apparent only to Chief Bratton who, by the way, recommended Charlie Beck for the new job. I suggest we give Chief Beck a little leeway. Changes can always be made later if his choices are found to be below par.

Leadership positions are extremely critical to the Department. However, placing someone into a position of leadership without first considering the individual's lack of people skills , or the negative impact they have had on morale at their previous commands is a recipe for continued failure. These are trying times for all of us that Serve and Protect in the field. To play "musical chairs", or to select ego-centric individuals, rather than true proven leaders of HUMAN RESOURCES is folly.

There is a saying in law enforcement that states something like; ¨When you do your job right, people are bound to get upset.¨ But keeping old sayings and clichés aside, if we remember this perhaps we can empathize with Chief Beck. One can speculate and criticize for the choices he has made. Anyone can agree that sometimes a lack of experience is as good as having experience. In many professions, alluding to the quality of experience or christening someone as being experienced can and has lead to complacency. Having the right mix of personalities and experience in your leadership team is critical. I congratulate Chief Beck, but hopefully he will be mindful to continually evaluate his agenda and priorities and modify them to reflect the fact that he is there to maintain a sound balance between keeping the citizenry he serves secure and ensuring a nurturing environment for his department.

Most of these people, both sworn and civilian, probably earned these promotions. I think Chief Beck would really have shown that he is supportive of us officers in the field if he had promoted Bill Snowden instead of Debbie McCarthy, who could capably serve in another bureau, to the Deputy Chief in charge of OWB position.

Wow, Bill Snowden up for an LAPD Commander position. That would definitely improve my morale. Congratulations Bill and to all the others who earned their promotions.

thanks admin
Are you really cool,realy very good blog

The comments to this entry are closed.

Chief Charlie Beck

Text-A-Tip

WebTip


Nixle


June 2015

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30        

iWATCH